Valentine's Day Cakes and Cupcakes! Click here for more info

Nightmare before Christmas Groom’s Cake (760)

The popular corpse bride cake and halloween wedding theme continues with this groom’s cake we created for a wedding at The Olde Mill Inn in Basking Ridge, NJ. The client provided us with the fantastic Jack & Sally topper.

Jack and Sally Grooms Cake

Topsy Turvy Jack and Sally Groom’s Cake

How’s this for a thoughtful testimonial. Nearly a year later Jason and Carolynn left us this comment on their very popular Groom’s cake. Thanks for making my day :)

This may be a bit belated but…Thats our cake!! Hehe! It’s been a year now since Carolynn and I got married at the Olde Mill Inn and I only thought now to look and see if our cake might have been posted on your site and Ta-Da! Here it is!

We highly recommend your work to everyone we know who is getting married. This cake was a big highlight at our wedding and once we built the entire Nightmare Before Christmas city around it it was truly amazing! People loved it!

Great job and beautiful work!

We look forward to working with you again for our future milestone events in our life.

All the best,

Jason & Carolynn

Want a quote?

No Obligation Quote!

Looking for a custom cake for your next celebration? Fill out our no obligation inquiry form!


Subscribe or Share our cakes!

Leave a Reply


  1. Justine says:

    so cute.
    however this is Nightmare before Christmas, not corpse bride.

  2. Anne says:

    Thanks Justine – I’ve corrected the title :)

  3. Bárbara says:

    woooooooooooooooooowwwwww,i looooooove all those cakes, there arent this kind of things in my city. congratulations!

  4. Heather says:

    I want my wedding theme to be nightmare before christmas and i would love that cake to be their.

  5. Sarah says:

    I am in Australia and am having a fright night themed wedding.. I absolutely love these wedding cake toppers, can anyone please tell me where I could find one?

    1. Cassie says:

      I too want this topper for my wedding cake, and I finally found it!! It is actually called Jack and Sally Spiral Hill Set, and you can find it at This is the cheapest site I have found, as others range from $59-$274. Good luck!!

  6. CHRISTINA says:


  7. Kayla says:

    This is by far my favorite cake!! One of my favorite movies too. I must say your cakes are amazing and very inspiring.. im about to be 20 years old and this is what im going to school for.. AMAZING!!

  8. Carlos says:

    WOW!!!With things like this…who’s not interested in living in USA????my god….if you come to Spain sometime,and open a business here,please let me know ‘cos I love all your cakes!!!(*_*)

  9. Gulen says:

    i have been visiting your websites for 3 years now, your cakes AMAZE me
    I would love to order very much ,but sadly, i do not live in the USA.

    one comment:
    if tim burton saw this cake, he would probably be so glad to have directed nightmare before christmas

    1. Anne says:

      Three years!? Thanks for the loyalty and I hope one day we can make a cake for you :)

  10. Melody says:

    this cake is beautiful!!! although i am a little upset someone else had my idea lol this cake is pretty much exactly what i want for my wedding.

    1. Anne says:

      Thanks Melody – you could also change it up a bit and add your own unique spin :)

Share with your friends